Three scores, three different things
The audit covers all three. Keeping them apart makes the findings easier to follow.
The 10 most important points
The findings with the widest effect on students, schools and the public record.
Test score cutoffs were reset in 2024 with no written rules.
DPI set new cut scores for the Forward Exam, PreACT Secure and ACT. Auditors found no written policies for how cut scores are changed. DPI itself said 2023-24 test results cannot be compared with earlier years. pp. 16–19
Student performance labels were renamed without a written policy.
In June 2024, “Proficient, Basic, Below Basic” became “Meeting, Approaching, Developing.” “Advanced” stayed. DPI surveyed educators and families first, but had no written policy on when or how labels may change. pp. 12–16
School report-card thresholds were reset in 2025, also without written policies.
New star-rating thresholds were used for the November 2025 report cards. DPI adopted the educator panel’s recommendations without changes, but had no written policies for producing report cards or changing thresholds. pp. 24–27
No school’s 2023-24 achievement score was allowed to fall.
After adjusting 2023-24 achievement scores downward, DPI used a school’s 2022-23 score whenever the new one would have been lower. DPI projected this for about 63.8% of schools in English language arts and 44.1% in math. DPI calls it a one-time step to keep report cards comparable. p. 39; DPI response
Possible declines went unexamined.
DPI estimated that 75 schools and 3 districts in English language arts, and 63 schools and 2 districts in math, would otherwise have scored lower than the year before. It did not check whether these were real declines. pp. 39–40
Report cards left out information the law requires.
Missing: a measure of whether achievement gaps are closing, the number of community service hours, and the number of AP courses offered and AP credits earned. DPI says it meets the law; auditors disagree. pp. 27–30
Separate school performance reports required by law were not produced.
DPI relied on report cards and its online dashboard instead, and did not send the Legislature the required 2023-24 summary. Several required items appeared in neither place. DPI wants the requirement removed. pp. 33–35
Not every struggling school got the recommendations the law requires.
The law calls for improvement recommendations to schools whose students fall below minimum standards on required tests. DPI’s programs targeted groups such as the lowest 5% of schools, so some schools were left out. p. 35
Ratings rose under the new thresholds.
Schools rated “meets expectations” or better went from 82.3% (2022-23) to 84.8% (2024-25). From 2023-24 to 2024-25, 20.2% of schools moved up one category and 10.1% moved down one. These are rating changes, not a measure of learning, and DPI notes 2022-23 results may reflect the pandemic. pp. 36–38
Several meetings were closed, and the legal question is in court.
Advisory committee meetings in 2024 and 2025 and the 2024 cut-score workshops were not publicly noticed or open. The 2025 rating workshops were open. A June 2026 lawsuit in Adams County asks whether such groups must meet in public; auditors made no recommendation. pp. 20–22, 31–32
10 obscure but salient details
Smaller facts in the report that help explain the bigger story.
DPI changed two-thirds of the educators’ recommended cut scores.
For the Forward Exam, DPI raised one-third of the recommended cut scores and lowered another third, saying it wanted consistent measurement across grades. p. 17
The yardstick changed.
In 2016, cut-score panels used the national NAEP test as a reference. In 2024 they used Forward Exam results and similar tests from Illinois, Michigan and Minnesota, and scores moved from a three-digit to a four-digit scale. DPI says only the reference point changed; auditors call it a change in process. pp. 18, 20
The new labels had a stated goal.
DPI’s review aimed to make labels reflect an “asset-based, growth mindset.” Descriptions shifted from “college content-readiness” to being “on-track for future learning.” pp. 13–15
PreACT Secure cut scores were set inside DPI.
Educators recommended new cut scores for the Forward Exam and ACT. For PreACT Secure, DPI set them internally to line up with the other two tests. p. 17
The 2024 cut-score workshop cost $372,500.
Four days and 88 Wisconsin educators. The vendor’s planning and facilitation was the largest share, at 40.2%. p. 17
One workshop’s cost rose 138.8%.
The rating-threshold workshop grew from $88,500 (2022 proposal) to $211,300 (2025) after DPI added a virtual session and a third in-person day. DPI did not pay more than the overall contract allowed. p. 30
The open-meetings fine print.
Advisers signed contracts with the test vendor “on behalf of DPI,” and DPI cited a 1998 Attorney General letter to argue open meetings law did not apply. DPI says it opened the 2025 rating workshops by choice, yet their slides said, “This meeting is subject to Wisconsin open meetings laws.” pp. 21, 31–32
No communications plan for the cut-score change.
DPI called such plans standard practice, but made none for the 2024 cut scores and could not document the informal feedback it said it received. p. 18
Some required facts are published nowhere.
Examples: each district’s method of reading instruction and reading textbook series, and how it compares with other districts in its athletic conference. DPI calls the law outdated; auditors note it was last amended in 2023. p. 34; LAB comment 10
Small schools may get no rating at all.
Schools and districts with fewer than 20 students taking certain tests receive no star rating, for privacy and statistical reasons. Districts without a high school also lack some required figures, such as arts participation. pp. 28–29
What it means for you
Practical points drawn from the report for four groups of readers.
Students
- “Meeting” is the new second-highest level, in the spot “Proficient” used to hold. The cutoffs changed too, so results from 2023-24 on don’t line up with older ones.
- Forward Exam scores now use four digits instead of three. A bigger number does not mean you did better than in an earlier year.
- The audit is about how the state set and reported scores. It does not grade any student’s work.
Parents
- Compare years with care. Test results from 2023-24 on can’t be compared with earlier years, and 2024-25 star ratings use new thresholds.
- A higher star rating may reflect the new thresholds. The audit reports how ratings moved, not whether learning improved.
- Some facts the law calls for aren’t in report cards, such as AP courses offered and your district’s reading method and textbooks. You can ask your school or district directly.
- Schools with fewer than 20 tested students get no star rating.
Voters
- Most findings concern process and openness: written rules, required reports and public meetings.
- DPI disputes several findings, and the Audit Bureau stands by them. Both responses are in the report.
- Milestones to watch: DPI’s progress report by March 30, 2027, and the Adams County open-meetings case.
- Testing and accountability vendor contracts total $73.9 million; $32.5 million was paid from July 2023 through December 2025.
Elected officials
- Decide whether to write a cut-score process into law or leave it to DPI. The report raises this as an issue for legislative consideration.
- Decide whether to keep, update or repeal the school performance report law (s. 115.38). DPI wants it removed; it was last amended in 2023.
- Decide whether the gap-closure requirement should stand as written. The auditors say DPI should either comply or ask the Legislature to change it.
- Review DPI’s March 30, 2027 progress report. State law also requires a standing committee in each house to review report cards every two years (s. 115.385(5)).
What DPI says, and what happens next
DPI’s response (State Superintendent Jill Underly, Nov. 16, 2026)
DPI says it administers tests and report cards in line with state law, calls several of the audit’s characterizations incorrect, and argues the audit overlooks federal requirements and the State Superintendent’s constitutional authority. It says it has written guidance and policies, will write a policy for report-card threshold changes, and will work with the Legislature to update or remove statutes it considers unworkable or outdated.
The Audit Bureau’s attached comments respond point by point and stand by its findings.
- DPI must report its progress on all 13 recommendations to the Joint Legislative Audit Committee by March 30, 2027.
- The Legislature could write the cut-score process into law, or leave it to DPI’s discretion. pp. 19–20
- Read the full report.